First Student: My favourite one is the top one because I like the contrasting white and black, it's cool and stands out. The other three both have red in and the red is a bold colour and slightly distracts me from the actual design of the ident.
Second Student: I think the second one is the best because the red outline highlights the shapes. It's not too bold and doesn't blend in with the background. I think the bottom two look like warning signs because of the red background, overall I think the white background is better.
Third Student: I prefer the bottom design because I like the colour, it stands out compared to the other three. I think the ones that are plainer don't stand out as much and are not quite as bold as the fourth one that has the red background.
Fourth Student: I think the bottom one is the best because I like how the red outlines it, more prominent and different. I like the top one but it's a bit too generic and I think the red and black colour surrounding the triangles separates up the design.
Fifth Student: I like the second design because of the red colour that surrounds the triangle. it stands out more to me compared to the other three. I prefer the white background and the red adds more depth to the Ident.